Logo horizontal ruler

  Archive

About Us Contact

Council Prohibits Leaving Donations for Homeless in Parks

By Anita Varghese
Special to The Lookout

May 10 -- Leaving food, clothing and other property for homeless people in city parks, adjacent sidewalks and parkways will soon be prohibited under a new law approved by the Santa Monica City Council Tuesday.

The move comes after City staff noticed more people in recent years donating food and clothing to the homeless by leaving those items in city parks and walking away. At times, large amounts of catered food from private parties have been left in city parks for the homeless to pick up, staff said.

Despite reservations by at least one council member, the law was approved unanimously

“So I guess it is okay to leave a picnic basket on your friend’s front step North of Montana, but not okay to leave food for the poor in the parks?” asked City Councilman Kevin McKeown.

“I am uncomfortable with this, but it is the right thing to do,” he said before voting for the ordinance. “There are places like OPCC that will store and serve food and clothing. I think it is humane to implement this ordinance, so long as we do it in conjunction with an education program.”

While the ordinance will add a new section and misdemeanor violation to the Parks Maintenance Code prohibiting the practice of leaving items in parks and walking away, it does not bar physically handing items directly to a homeless person.

According to City staff, food that is not refrigerated can become contaminated, endangering the health of those who eat it, and encourages rodent and other types of infestations.

Leaving behind food, as well as clothing and blankets, detracts from the park’s beauty, can interfere with recreational activities and can obstruct the work of maintenance crews.

“The reason we are recommending this is that the practice of leaving donated food in the parks is damaging to the park environment,” said City Attorney Marsha Moutrie, whose office, along with Community Cultural Services (CSS), recommended the ordinance.

A new ordinance is necessary, Moutrie said, because the only other City law that comes close to prohibiting this kind of activity is a littering law.

“This is not littering,” Moutrie said. “Littering depends on intent. The intent of just discarding a piece of trash is much different than leaving food and clothing in the park for people, which can be seen as a charitable act.”

City staff will return to the council with additional recommendations on how to communicate to the public and assist in finding other ways to donate to the homeless, such as giving to nonprofit organizations.

Council also directed staff to ensure that the new law is posted on park signs and suggested that they consider signage informing the public on how to make donations.

Community activist Jerry Rubin testified against the new law.

“I never realized there were throngs of people coming with food and clothing and leaving them for the homeless,” he told the council. “There are people who are hungry at certain moments and cold at certain moments.

“There should be something done than an outright ban with no other compassionate alternatives in place.”

 

“I am uncomfortable with this, but it is the right thing to do.” Kevin McKeown

 

 

“Littering depends on intent. The intent of just discarding a piece of trash is much different than leaving food and clothing in the park for people, which can be seen as a charitable act.” Marsha Moutrie

 

Lookout Logo footer image
Copyright 1999-2008 surfsantamonica.com. All Rights Reserved.
Footer Email icon