| By Jorge
Casuso
February 12 -- Imagine a team of “ambassadors”
who patrol the streets to keep them safe and clean. Or a parking
meter you feed instead of handing your spare change to a panhandler.
Or a “hygiene facility” where the homeless can drop
in to shower and wash their clothes.
Those are three key ways to address the homeless problem in Downtown
Santa Monica according to an Urban Institute report released by
the City last month.
The Bayside District Corporation has already proposed a clean
and safe or “ambassador” program for the district
and currently administers the Dolphin Change program where spare
change has added up to $125,000 in grants to local homeless social
service organizations since its launch in 1995.
Despite the efforts, business owners and employees complained
to consultants that the homeless remain a major stumbling block
to conducting business Downtown, which is home to one-third of
Santa Monica’s homeless, according to a countywide census
two years ago.
They lie on sidewalks, sleep in doorways, beg for money, occupy
restaurant tables and street benches, even urinate on merchandise
displayed outside. These were among the specific complaints listed.
“Business attitudes reflected a desire to help with the
problem if viable approaches can be found as well as a feeling
of being ‘fed up’ and frustrated,” the consultants
wrote. “Most business people wanted the problems they described
to go away, however that could be made to happen.”
Some of the biggest complaints focused on public safety, which
was hampered by slow police responses and an unwillingness on
the part of business owners and workers to take time off to address
a problem that won't go away, consultants said.
The feeling was that the Police Department’s Homeless Liaison
Program (HLP) team worked “very hard,” responding
to 2,400 incidents and making 2,900 periodic checks on property
and open space citywide. Still, consultants wrote, the team “was
not having the effects desired.”
The police department also was widely viewed as not doing enough,
despite spending more than $2 million in the 2005-06 fiscal year
on the homeless citywide and reportedly making 1,796 arrests of
transients across Santa Monica, not including citations issued.
“People cited slow response times when they did call the
police, which they also said the police deny,” consultants
wrote. “One suggestion was that business people be able
to email their requests for assistance, which would leave a timed
and dated paper trail.
“Another response we heard several times was that business
people usually did not call the police, although an incident warranted
doing so, because it would take too much of the owner’s
or employee’s time, and ‘wouldn’t do any good
anyway.’”
While the Downtown business community is helping to provide jobs
for those who live on the streets, it should “play a much
more prominent role in the city’s homeless reduction efforts,”
consultants said.
One key way to improve the appearance of Downtown and make the
streets safer would be to establish “Clean & Safe Teams,”
or ambassadors, which could operate 24 hours, seven days a week.
The cleaning teams would sweep and power wash sidewalks, empty
trash bins, pick up garbage and human waste and erase graffiti,
consultants said. Bayside officials have been pushing a similar
proposal.
The safety teams would patrol on foot and bicycles, serving “as
an extra set of ‘eyes and ears’ for law enforcement
and property owners,” link the homeless with service providers
and “prevent vandalism and other undesirable behavior,”
consultants said.
The report also suggested ways to reduce panhandling by engaging
businesses in “a serious and sustained anti-panhandling
campaign.”
The campaign would focus on educating the public about where most
panhandled money goes, how it enables the homeless to stay on
the streets and what alternative modes of giving are available.
While the Bayside District’s Dolphin Change program provides
an alternative by allowing strollers to drop change into life-sized
dolphin banks, “most people felt it doesn’t work,”
consultants said.
“There is little or no sustained explanation of what the
dolphins are there for, they aren’t in enough places, and
also possibly the direct beneficiaries are not clear or personal
enough.”
One suggestion was to follow a model established by Baltimore’s
downtown district, which installed old parking meters in many
locations, especially where panhandlers congregate.
“When a person inserts a coin and turns the handle, the
needle does not go from 0 to 30 minutes – instead, it turns
from Despair to Hope,” consultants wrote, noting that the
proceeds are distributed to homeless assistance programs.
Whether it’s dropping change in meters along the Promenade,
in hotels, stores and restaurants, or handing donations at tables
staffed by volunteers from social service programs, educating
members of the public will be the key to success, the report stated.
“Alternative giving opportunities would need to involve
posters, flyers, and handouts explaining why giving to panhandlers
does not help people leave homelessness,” the report stated.
The final key recommendation in the Urban Institute report is
to establish a hygiene facility or drop-in center, or both, Downtown.
It is something that would be welcomed by the homeless, who “must
improvise, go without bathing or washing their clothes, or resort
to the inappropriate use… of public or quasi-public spaces
to take care of their bodily needs,” the report said.
“To relieve pressures to use the restrooms of downtown businesses,
or else to use the streets and business property as a bathroom,
the business community should consider a hygiene center just for
homeless people, in the downtown area,” the report concluded.
|